Three feminist eco-horror dystopias! #SciFiMonth #NovellasinNovember

I’m not sure how #NovellasInNovember officially defines a novella, but, given that I usually read much longer books, I’m going to go for anything under 200 pages. And Naomi Booth’s Sealed is 170 pages of pure, brilliant horror. I heard Booth speak about this novel at the Durham Book Festival and instantly knew I had to read it, especially when I saw it had Victoria (Eve’s Alexandria)’s endorsement. Booth imagines a near-future Australia infected by cutis, a disease that causes skin to seal over all the orifices in the body. Alice, who is nearing the end of her pregnancy, and her partner, Pete, leave Sydney for a small town in the Blue Mountains because they believe the environment will be cleaner and safer; as Alice puts it, ‘I look out at the mountains and the blue-grey haze around them. It’s not like the smog back in the city; there’s nothing yellow or septic-looking about it. The softening of the mountain edges is just distance, and eucalypt oil on the air, and low, fine cloud.’ But, as Booth discussed at her festival event, our ideas about detox, health and rural space are often chimeras; living in a polluted world means that we are polluted too. Often, climate change fiction posits a contrast between unspoiled natural places, often located in developing countries, and Western urban sprawl, but Booth has little time for this, writing about a village located near the Citarum river in Indonesia, ‘the river doesn’t appear to move at all as the reporter walks alongside it; it’s covered over with greyish debris, a barely-drifting scurf of different bits of plastic.’ The ideas explored in Sealed are inherently gripping, but Booth also writes incredibly precise prose and place.

Some shots from my trip to the Blue Mountains in June.

Cynan Jones’s Stillicide is even shorter; technically, it’s 174 pages, but the wide spacing of his short paragraphs means it clocks in at far fewer words than Booth’s novella. Jones originally wrote this series of interlinked short stories to be read on the radio, and from what I can tell from this version, they’d have sounded incredible. Like Sealed, Stillicide is concerned with the displacement of people; this time, their homes on the outskirts of the city are being bulldozed to make way for the ‘Ice Dock’, a huge iceberg designed to solve the urban water crisis. As in his previous novellas, The Dig and Cove, his prose is beautifully sparse and efficient. He has fun with the word ‘stillicide’, which is strung between every story: it means ‘a continual dropping of water’ but also ‘a right or duty relating to the collection of water from or onto adjacent land’. For me, though, there’s also an instinctive if incorrect meaning to the word that filters through Jones’s stories; the ‘cide’ ending makes me think of ‘suicide’, and so ‘stillicide’ sounds to me like a kind of death through standing still, through inaction. While it’s obviously deeply concerned with climate change, Stillicide doesn’t fit the ‘feminist eco-horror dystopia’ tag quite as well as the other two books in this post, but I couldn’t resist that title.


The BBC Radio 4 advert for Stillicide.

Rory Powers’s 370-page YA novel, Wilder Girls, is definitely not a novella, but it’s so thematically relevant I decided to make it part of this post anyway. Hetty, Reese and Byatt are pupils at the Raxter School for Girls, located on an isolated island. When the novel opens, the school has been cut off from the mainland for eighteen months because of the spread of the Tox, which causes the girls’ bodies to mutate in gruesome ways and also infects the local flora and fauna (there’s more than a hint of Jeff VanderMeer’s Annihilation in this novel – an infected bear even plays a key role – but fortunately it’s not nearly as disturbing!). With food supplies running low and the death toll rising, the girls come to realise that their days on the island are numbered. Great premise, but this book felt too bound by YA conventions for me to really enjoy it, and the obligatory link to climate change was unnecessary – as the two novellas above show, we have no shortage of books that do this well. The pace is, weirdly, both slow and breathless, and the three main characters feel interchangeable. I would have liked this to spend a LOT more time delving into the life of the school and the background to the Tox, and less time on action sequences; there’s also very little on how the girls experience their changing bodies. Even more than VanderMeer, this book reminded me of Ann Halam’s Dr Franklin’s Island, which also focuses on three protagonists forced into a bizarre medical experiment. But while I found the morphing sequences in that book unforgettable – I last read it more than fifteen years ago! – Wilder Girls didn’t make much of an impression on me.


Dr Franklin’s Island: maybe a YA classic, maybe a book I’d hate if I read it now!

I also read Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol (thankfully, only 104 pages in my Kindle version) as part of #NovellasinNovember, but as it’s not remotely thematically relevant to this post, I’ve put my review on Goodreads instead. You can read it here. (Dickens fans may want to avoid.)


18 thoughts on “Three feminist eco-horror dystopias! #SciFiMonth #NovellasinNovember

  1. Novellas seem to be exclusively defined by word count, so it’s hard to judge by the number of pages. My general rule of thumb is under 150 pages, but if the type is large or there aren’t that many words on a page, I might go up to 180 or even 200.

    I also read a Cynan Jones novella this month! (To be reviewed as part of a big roundup tomorrow.) I think I’d like the one you read better, though; the animal cruelty in The Dig troubled me.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Sealed seems to be the classic slow burn: it keeps cropping up here and there in the blogosphere, over the last year, and increasingly in the last few months. (I think it might even have been on last year’s Not the Booker Prize shortlist?) It sounds rather up my alley…

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes, it seems to be a slow build – first published in 2017 but Dead Ink did a new paperback run (with new cover) this year. It deserves it; it’s incredibly well-written and gripping. Booth made it sound like it would be REALLY gory in her talk, but the gore’s no worse than a lot of similar books I’ve read eg Wilder Girls itself is probably as bad, and aimed at YA!


  3. Pingback: November Challenges Wrap-Up & December Reading Plans | Laura Tisdall

  4. I can’t decide if Sealed sounds incredible or if it would give me too much anxiety!

    Incidentally A Christmas Carol is the only Dickens that I’ve read, and I remember liking it in the moment but now I frequently forget about it and accidentally claim that I have never read Dickens, so, that probably says something.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I don’t think I’ve seen any reviews comment on the fact that Tox might lead readers to think of “toxic shock syndrome,” which is linked to incorrect tampon use, which makes me think of menstruation and changing bodies. Did you get any vibes that maybe this novel was about puberty in some way?

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: 2019 in Books: Commendations and Disappointments | Laura Tisdall

  7. Pingback: Recommended Reading for a Pandemic | Laura Tisdall

  8. Pingback: Announcing the NOT the Wellcome Prize and Blog Tour | Bookish Beck

  9. Pingback: ‘You are in the house and the house is in the woods’: Catherine House by Elisabeth Thomas | Laura Tisdall

  10. Pingback: Mind the gaps: Exit Management by Naomi Booth | Laura Tisdall

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s